28 November 2018

Mason Institute advises Scottish government on organ donation policy



On Tuesday 27th November 2018 MI Deputy Directors and policy portfolio leads, Emily Postan and Annie Sorbie, attended the Health and Sport Committee to provide evidence on our MI consultation response to the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Bill. This Bill makes provision for the authorisation of the removal and use of parts of the body of a deceased person for transplantation and other purposes.  Significantly, it proposes that Scotland move from the current ‘opt-in’ system, in which an individual’s organs may be used for transplantation only when they (or, after their death, a close relative) have explicitly authorised this, to one of ‘deemed authorisation’. Under the proposed law, adults who have not formally registered their wishes will be deemed to have authorised the use of their organs for transplant purposes, with some exceptions for particular groups of persons and types of body parts. Under the new law the option to ‘opt-out’ of donation will be placed on a statutory footing (as will a third option of explicitly ‘opting in’).   

In our MI consultation response we had outlined our broad support for the policy objectives of the Bill, but emphasised that legislation is but one step towards improving donation and transplantation rates, and that a holistic package of regulatory, social and ethical measures are necessary to secure these objectives. These include the need for far-reaching public information programmes, training and resourcing of transplant coordination professionals, and comprehensive evidence-gathering about the impacts of the legislative changes. 
Also giving evidence in this meeting of the Committee were Professor Alison Britton, Professor of Healthcare and Medical Law and Convenor of the Health and Medical Law Sub Committee for the Law Society of Scotland, and Dr Calum MacKellar, Director of Research at the Scottish Council on Human Bioethics.

In her oral evidence Dr Postan was able to answer the Committee’s questions on several issues. 

The Committee was interested in the question of how the respective interests would be weighed and met under the new legislation, particularly whether relatives’ wishes might, in practice, often override those of deceased persons as they do under the current law. Under the proposed law, relatives will not have a legal entitlement to override the express or deemed wishes of the deceased, but if they present evidence that the most recent views of the deceased differ from those registered or deemed to hold, then this will be taken into account. Dr Postan suggested that providing guidance to transplant coordinators, to support them in judging what counts as reasonable evidence of changed wishes, could be of great value and noted the risks of sending mixed messages to family members about their degree of their involvement in decision-making when the deceased person’s wishes are not ambiguous. Along with the other witnesses she emphasised the need for a far-reaching communications and training strategy to support the changes in culture and expectations that will be needed if the new law is to function as intended. 

Dr Postan responded to the Committee’s questions about the protection of adults lacking capacity under the proposed law by suggesting that as currently drafted the law perhaps reflects too binary a conception of capacity and that it ought to be interpreted in a way that is consistent with the recognition under the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000 that capacity can fluctuate and should be assessed in a context specific manner and that individuals should be supported to make decisions when they can. 

The Committee reflected concerns of some consultees about the ethics and legality of also making pre-death procedures (preparatory to donation) subject to ‘deemed authorisation’. Dr Postan responded that even though these procedures might not be for the clinical benefit of the patient, as long as they are minimally invasive and do not cause discomfort or hasten death, they may be seen as being in the best interests of the patient (and therefore both lawful and ethical), insofar as they are a necessary and anticipated part of fulfilling their wishes to act as donors. 

This work exemplifies the MI’s commitment to bringing our interdisciplinary approach and research to bear on practical questions. If you would like to bring a consultation to our attention or to discuss the possibility of working with us on a particular policy matter, please get in touch with us by emailing Emily Postan and Annie Sorbie.

2 comments:

  1. Thanks to dr.ezomo for his good work I never believe that ALS has cure, I was ALS over 3 year now before I came across a comment about how
    dr.ezomo cure ALS and herpes disease but when I saw it i have it in mind
    that he cant cure ALS I just decided to give it a try I contact him that
    night luckily to me he replied me, but I dont believe him I thought it was
    a scam but I still hold on to see the work of Dr ezomo if he is saying the
    truth he ask for some details about me i gave him all he needed and I
    waited to see his reply to my problem after all, he told me to go for check
    up and I went for HIV test I cant believe I was negative,am so happy and
    grateful to God for using Dr ezomo to cure me, that is the reason why i
    decided to write this wonderful testimony of our i was cured, i recommend
    Dr ezomo to you all around the world,contact him on his Email dr.ezomorootandherbals@gmail.com
    dr.ezomo for helping me at this young age if you need help contact,
    He can also cure so many sickness
    {1}HIV And AIDS
    {2}Diabetes
    {3}Epilepsy
    {4} Blood Cancer
    {5} HPV
    {6} ALS
    {7}herpes

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am John Danilla from UK( northern ireland), i want to share a
    testimony on how a powerful spell caster cured my HIV disease, i was
    diagnosed of this disease, in the year 2009, last week i saw a testimony on
    Dr.Akioya on how he cured an HIV patient, so i contacted him through phone
    and he asked me to email him, which idid, so he told me that all my
    problems is over and then he decided to do an healing spell spell for me so
    after he finished it, he told me to wait for just 24 hours and then i
    should go for a test, so i really did as he had said, so my greatest
    surprised when i went to the hospital to go for an HIV test, the Medical
    doctor diagnosed that, i am now HIV negetative at first i was amazed and
    now i have come to realise that this spell caster Dr. Akioya is a very
    powerful one and a real spell caster. So viewers of this should please join
    me in my celebration for i am the happiest man on earth today and if you
    want to contact him, you can do this via his email
    (drakioya17spellhome@gmail.com or call him or whatsapp him
    +2348105257464. or you can visit is website;
    http://drakioyaherbalcenter.home.blog
    https://drakioyaherbalhome.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete